My Son is Smart, Slow and Stubborn
Ask the Experts: My fifth-grader is in the gifted and talented program, but he is also easily distracted, rigid and does everything slowly. How can I help?
Question: My son is pretty smart and was just accepted into his school's "gifted and talented" program. The problem is he
Got a Question?
If your fifth-grader has an academic or school-related behavior problem you would like help solving, send it to myfifthgrader@greatschools.net.

More on GreatSchools.net

does everything slowly including copying a simple assignment, taking a bath and eating.

He also gets extremely distracted. For example, when he is putting on his socks he might get distracted by a book and stop to read it. He partially listens to what his teacher says in school and then cannot complete his work correctly.

His consequence is to redo his work again and again. I consulted with his pediatrician to find out if he has ADD (attention-deficit disorder), but his evaluation is that "this is his personality — self-centered, rigid and strong-minded."

He can do an excellent job in his own way, but never follows guidelines or requirements. What can I do without struggling with him every day?

Answer: The first thing to do is decide the issues that are important enough for you to worry about. If you can prioritize those and let the other ones run their course, you will reduce the amount of struggle and conflict.

I have encountered several children like this and you have to pick your battles carefully. In some instances, operating at a slow speed is a form of resistance and a passive-aggressive response ("You can't make me go any faster").

I respond to this by emphasizing the positive and providing firm, consistent limits and boundaries on the areas I have identified as important.

There are some simple approaches that work for stubborn children. For example, the use of a kitchen timer for the completion of a household task or a school assignment helps the child modulate his time on task. In school the teacher could initially shorten the assignments and set the timer for a certain time limit. If your son responds successfully, then provide a reward for him. The work can be gradually increased as he demonstrates success. In addition, limit the number of directions.

One last bit of caution. Children who have these characteristics often look for chances to engage in an argument. Avoiding an argument or conflict is important, and using redirection techniques can reduce tension. The key for all children is consistency and predictability. Look for the strengths in your child and he will shine for you.

Dr. Joseph Gianesin is a professor at Springfield College School of Social Work and a program and behavioral consultant for public schools in Massachusetts. He has more than 25 years of experience as a child and family therapist, a school social worker and a school administrator.

Advice from our experts is not a substitute for medical or other professional advice and services from a qualified health-care provider familiar with your unique situation. We recommend consulting a qualified professional if you have concerns about your child's medical or emotional condition.

December 2006

Email us your feedback
Name (optional):   

Email (optional):    

Yes, I agree to the GreatSchools Terms of Use and give GreatSchools permission to post my comments for other parents to read. Note: Your email address is required if you would like a response from GreatSchools.net.

Comments From GreatSchools.net Users
05/5/2008:
"this information was great. I have struggle with my son for some time now and I was thinking that he too had add or adhd I had him tested and he is fine; but he is slow and whats to do things his way and we will fight until i gave up. "

11/6/2007:
"I am so happy to know there are other people dealing with the same issues. My daughter is in the gifted and talented classes. She's 10 years old and in fifth grade. I tell her she can go play outside after she gets her homework done (which the school says should take 1 hour). There has been 'maybe' one day that she was able to play after homework. From homework to showers to eating - it takes forever. When I try to use a timer - she throws a fit. I want her to learn about time management through real life consequences (like not playing outside, going to bed right after her shower because she took too long, and eating cold food). None of this seems to bother her. UGH! I've been told that it is a phase and will soon pass (I've been dealing with this since she was in 3rd grade). I'm worried about high school, college, and the real world. "

10/17/2007:
"My son is the same, so smart, he can work and do quality work when he wants, but takes for ever to finish anything, take a shower, even answer a simple question he takes his time, we tried the timer, but he still needs more motivation, sometimes it is so sad seen him getting worse grades every time because time is never enough for him. He is in seven grade now, and we do no wht else to do other than be with him, I mean really in front of him watching him working and taking his attention back every 5 minutes or less."

12/28/2006:
"I have a similar situation with my 10 year old son, who is in fifth grade. He is extremely smart and often argumental - I find that if I make time for him to talk about the things he enjoys, I can then engage him in talking about things he normally doesn’t want to listen to. As the older brother of a 4 and 5 year old, I am constantly reminding him about the importance of leading by example and that sort of keeps him on track for some time. He needs constant personal and school reminders, so I try to put notes and make lists for him everywhere around the house – just need to stay on top of it, so that he is consistent too. One thing I noticed with my son's 4th. grade teacher last year and how she got him to engage in class, was by praising him with big words - tons of encouragement!! I too have conversations with him about the fact that he is special in his own unique way – he processes his thoughts in a much faster way than most people do and when he puts his mind in to something he is GrEAT at it!!"

12/27/2006:
"I agree with what you discuss in this article. My son has been vaery arguementive. I have been trying to ignore him or give him the silent treatment. I will try redirection Ms Reid Bronx, NY"

12/19/2006:
"I have a sixth grader, she's in a gifted math and science class. We have to remind her of everything she has to do, like don't forget to brush your teeth, wash your face, take a shower. do your homework. I noticed that if we don't remind her she'll forget those things. We're trying to teach her how to be independent but she relies on us to much, like doing her homework, she wants us to be part of it, a simple vocabulary if she doesn't know the meaning she'll ask us, we told her over and over that if she doesn't know the meaning we have big dictionary, but she's very lazy. And she needs help focusing and paying attention to details. I can go on and on. By the way she's the only child. If you can give advice to help my daughter I'll appreciate it so much."

tracker